OwlSheets Students
← Exit

Engines in the Valley: Testing a Park Shuttle

0 / 11

Engines in the Valley: Testing a Park Shuttle

Use noise and air data to judge a plan that cuts traffic in a national park.

Monitoring the traffic

Read the passage and Table 1. Then answer questions 1–4.

A Road Trip to Silverfall Valley

1In July, sixth grader Ezekiel Marchand and his mother drove to Silverfall Valley, a national park with granite cliffs and tall waterfalls. The park and its numbers are made up, but they are based on real parks. One road runs up the narrow valley floor. On summer days, about 5,000 cars a day drive it, and the parking lots fill by 9 a.m., so drivers circle the loop looking for spaces. At the visitor center, Ezekiel met Ranger Ingrid Solano, a scientist who studies the park's air and natural sounds.

2Ranger Solano explained that the park monitors two impacts of traffic. Sound stations record all day, and a computer counts the share of minutes from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. when an engine can be heard. Small tubes clipped to posts soak up nitrogen dioxide (NO₂), a gas in car exhaust that can harm people's lungs and plants. Each tube hangs for the same two weeks in July, then goes to a lab, which reports the amount in parts per billion (ppb). One station stands at a backcountry camp 6 km from any road, where the engine noise heard comes mostly from airplanes passing high overhead.

3The park wants a plan for next summer. The plan must cut the cars on the valley road to 2,500 a day or fewer, leave room for at least 12,000 visitors a day to reach the trailheads, and cost no more than $3 million a year. It also must not add any new pavement, because pavement would cover the valley's meadows.

4After the park chose a plan, the rangers checked its first summer with the same stations. They also kept stations beside Pine Gap Road, a road in another part of the park where nothing changed.

Table 1. Silverfall Valley in July, Before Any Change
StationDistance from roadEngine heard (% of min.)NO₂ (ppb)
Roadside overlook20 m8514
Meadow trail300 m507
Waterfall trail1 km304
Backcountry camp6 km52
1.

At the roadside overlook, an engine could be heard during times as large a share of the minutes as at the backcountry camp, and the NO₂ was times as high.

2.
Which statement best describes Table 1?
Question 2 options
3.
Why does the park keep a station at the backcountry camp, 6 km from any road?
Question 3 options
4.
Why does every NO₂ tube hang for the same two weeks in July?
Question 4 options

Choosing a plan

Use paragraph 3 and Table 2 to answer questions 5–7.

Table 2. Plans for Next Summer (estimates for the valley road)
OptionCars per dayVisitors per dayCost per yearNew pavement?
A. Free shuttle; cars park outside60015,000$2.4 millionNo
B. Reservations for 2,000 cars a day2,0006,000$0.5 millionNo
C. Wider road + meadow parking lot6,00018,000$1.5 millionYes
D. Speed limit 55 → 40 km/h5,00015,000$0.1 millionNo
Cars per day for Option A counts park trucks and the few cars of people staying in the valley; the buses are not counted.
5.
Which option meets all four requirements in paragraph 3?
Question 5 options
6.
Option B cuts more cars than the park requires and costs only $0.5 million a year. What is its main drawback?
Question 6 options
7.

Compared with today's 5,000 cars a day, Option A would cut the cars on the valley road by %.

Did the shuttle work?

The park chose Option A. Table 3 compares the July before the shuttle with the first July of the shuttle. Use it and paragraph 4 to answer questions 8–11.

Table 3. July Before and After the Shuttle
StationNoise before (%)Noise after (%)NO₂ before (ppb)NO₂ after (ppb)
Roadside overlook8535146
Meadow trail502073
Backcountry camp5522
Pine Gap roadside80821313
Noise = share of minutes from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. when an engine could be heard. The valley had about 15,000 visitors a day in the July before the shuttle and about 16,000 a day in the first July of the shuttle.
8.
Underline each result that is evidence the shuttle reduced the impact of traffic in the valley.

9.
Why is it useful that the readings beside Pine Gap Road barely changed?
Question 9 options
10.
The park wants to keep checking whether the shuttle keeps working in the years ahead. Which plan is best?
Question 10 options
11.
A park neighbor says, "The shuttle did not work. The backcountry camp readings did not change at all." Do you agree? Write a claim, use at least two pieces of data from Tables 1 and 3 and the passage, and explain your reasoning.