OwlSheets Students
← Exit

Teen Court and the First Written Laws

0 / 11

Teen Court and the First Written Laws

Use a timeline and adapted ancient laws to trace the idea of the rule of law.

The handbook and the timeline

Read the page from a made-up teen court handbook and the timeline. Then answer the questions.

Ridgeway Teen Court Handbook: Why We Have a Rulebook

1Welcome to Ridgeway Teen Court. Here, students who have broken a school or city rule for the first time, such as damaging property, appear before a jury of other students. Before every hearing, the student and the family receive a copy of this handbook. It lists the rules, the steps of a hearing and the range of sentences, such as 10 to 30 hours of community service. Jurors may not invent a new punishment or give more hours than the handbook allows.

2Why so many written rules? The answer goes back thousands of years. For most of history, laws were customs carried in people's memories, and whoever judged a case decided what the custom meant. Writing laws down made them harder to bend. One of the oldest known written codes comes from King Ur-Nammu of Ur, in Sumer. About 350 years later, King Hammurabi of Babylon had about 282 laws carved on stone pillars and set up in public. Many of his penalties were very harsh, and a penalty often depended on whether a person was a noble, a commoner or enslaved.

3In early Rome, judges came from the patricians, a group of wealthy old families. Plebeians, the ordinary citizens, said patrician judges twisted unwritten customs to favor themselves. In 494 BCE many plebeians walked out of the city in protest. They won officials of their own and kept pressing for written laws. About 450 BCE, Rome's laws were set up in the Forum on twelve tablets, and Romans treated them as the base of their law for centuries. Even so, one table banned marriage between patricians and plebeians, a rule Romans dropped only a few years later.

4These codes did not treat everyone equally, but they planted an idea that grew over many centuries: the rule of law. Under the rule of law, rules are written and known in advance, a fair process decides guilt before anyone is punished, and the same rules bind leaders and judges as well as ordinary people.

Timeline: Written Law Through Time
DatePlaceEvent
About 2100 BCEUr, in SumerUr-Nammu's code; many fines in silver
About 1754 BCEBabylonHammurabi's laws carved on stone
About 621 BCEAthensDraco's laws: death for many crimes
About 594 BCEAthensSolon replaces most of Draco's laws
494 BCERomePlebeians walk out and win tribunes
About 450 BCERomeTwelve Tables set up in the Forum
529 CEConstantinopleJustinian's code gathers Roman laws
1215EnglandMagna Carta: no jail except by law
1791United StatesBill of Rights: due process of law

Notes: Solon's new laws were much milder than Draco's. Magna Carta says no free man may be imprisoned except by the lawful judgment of his equals or by the law of the land. Due process of law means a fair legal process, such as a trial, must come before the government takes away a person's life, liberty or property.
1.
Use the timeline. Round your answer to the nearest hundred years.

Rome's Twelve Tables were set up about years after Hammurabi's laws were carved.

2.
Which pair of timeline entries shows a cause and its effect, according to paragraph 3 of the handbook?
Question 2 options
3.
Which timeline entry best shows that people could change a written code when they thought it was too harsh?
Question 3 options

Read the laws

These laws are adapted from translations. Read them, then answer the questions.

Hammurabi's Code (about 1754 BCE)

Law 1. If a man accuses another man of murder but cannot prove it, the accuser shall be put to death.

Law 3. If a man comes forward as a witness in a case where a life is at stake, and he cannot prove what he said, he shall be put to death.

Law 53. If a man is too lazy to keep his dike strong, and it breaks and floods the farmland, he shall replace the grain that was ruined.

Laws 215–217. If a doctor saves a noble's life with surgery, he shall receive 10 shekels of silver. If the patient is a commoner, he shall receive 5 shekels. If the patient is a slave, the slave's owner shall pay 2 shekels.

The Twelve Tables (about 450 BCE, as quoted by later writers)

Table III. A person who admits a debt, or who has been judged to owe it, shall have 30 days to pay.

Table VII. If a tree's branches hang over a neighbor's land, they shall be trimmed to a height of 15 feet.

Table IX. A judge appointed by law who is found to have taken a bribe shall be put to death.

Table IX. Putting to death any person who has not been convicted is forbidden.

Table XI. Marriage between patricians and plebeians is not allowed.

4.
Why would Hammurabi's Laws 1 and 3 punish a person who accuses falsely or cannot back up his testimony?
Question 4 options
5.
Sort each law: does it apply the same way whatever a person's rank, or does it set people apart by rank (noble, commoner, enslaved, patrician or plebeian)?
6.
Draw a line from each Ridgeway Teen Court rule to the ancient law it most closely echoes.
7.
Tables III and VII deal with debts and tree branches. What do they suggest about the Twelve Tables?
Question 7 options

The rule of law

Use the handbook, the timeline and the laws.

8.
Which two timeline entries carry forward the idea in Table IX that no one may be put to death without being convicted? Choose two.
Question 8 options
9.
A new juror says, "Hammurabi's laws were fair because they were written down and set up in public." Which response is best supported by the handbook and the laws?
Question 9 options
10.
Ridgeway jurors may not give more hours of service than the handbook allows. Which part of the rule of law does this rule show best?
Question 10 options
11.
Claim: which did more to build the rule of law, Hammurabi's Code or Rome's Twelve Tables? Make a claim, use at least two details from the handbook, the timeline or the laws as evidence, and explain your reasoning.