OwlSheets Students
← Exit

One Afternoon or 600,000 Years? Changes to a Farm County's Surface

0 / 9

One Afternoon or 600,000 Years? Changes to a Farm County's Surface

Compare fast and slow geoscience processes using rates from a dry year.

A dry year on the farm

Read the passage and study the table. Then answer the questions.

The Driest Year

1This was the driest year that Nadia Haddad's family can remember on their wheat farm in Crane County. Only 23 cm of rain fell between January and October, about half the usual amount. Many fields were plowed but bare, because the crop sprouted poorly or never came up at all. Crane County sits on a wide, nearly flat plain, cut only by one river valley.

2In April, a windstorm with gusts near 80 km/h swept across the county, and the sky turned brown by midafternoon. When the wind died down, Nadia's father checked the marked stakes the family had pushed into a bare field. About 5 mm of topsoil had blown away in a single afternoon, and neighbors on many farms across the county reported the same. Fine dust from the storm settled on cars and windowsills more than 100 km away.

3In August, a thunderstorm dumped 6 cm of rain in less than an hour onto the hard, dry ground. Water raced across the fields instead of soaking in. Within three hours it had cut a gully 2 m deep and about 500 m long along the edge of one field. Afterward, the bottom of the gully was scattered with chunks of soil and small stones torn from its sides.

4For her science project, Nadia compared these events with slower changes, which are hard to notice in one lifetime and are usually found by measuring and calculating. A county soil scientist told her that in this area about 1 cm of new topsoil forms in roughly 200 years, as rock breaks down and plant remains decay and mix in. Nadia also studied the valley of the Red Willow River, which winds through the county. The valley is about 40 km long and 60 m deep, and geologists estimate the river has been cutting it for about 600,000 years. She organized what she learned in the table below.

Nadia's table of surface changes
ChangeAmountTime it tookArea affected
Dust storm5 mm of topsoil removed1 afternoonMany farms in the county
Flash floodGully 2 m deep3 hoursOne field edge
Topsoil forming1 cm built upAbout 200 yearsWhole county
River valley60 m deepAbout 600,000 yearsValley 40 km long
1.
Why did the dry year make the April windstorm so damaging to the fields?
Question 1 options
2.

At the rate the soil scientist gave, about how many years would it take for new topsoil to replace the 5 mm lost in the dust storm? years

3.
Why did the August storm cut such a deep gully so quickly?
Question 3 options
4.
Sort each change to the land by how long it takes.

Comparing time and size scales

Use Nadia's table and paragraph 4. Show your work on scrap paper.

5.
The valley is 60 m (60,000 mm) deep and took about 600,000 years to form.

On average, about how much deeper did the valley get each year? mm per year

6.

At the valley's average rate, how many years would the river need to cut down 2 m (2,000 mm), as deep as the August gully? years

7.
Which change in Nadia's table was both fast and spread over a large area?
Question 7 options
8.
A neighbor says one giant flood must have carved the Red Willow valley. Which explanation is better supported by Nadia's data?
Question 8 options
9.
Nadia's cousin says events that last one afternoon, like the dust storm, hardly matter for shaping Earth's surface compared with slow processes. Do you agree? Make a claim, use at least two numbers from the table or your answers, and explain your reasoning.