OwlSheets Students
← Exit

Thin Soil, Strong Springs: Finding Resources in Tamarack Gap

0 / 13

Thin Soil, Strong Springs: Finding Resources in Tamarack Gap

Use soil pits and spring flows to explain why a mountain valley's resources are uneven.

Where the soil is

Read the survey notes and Table 1, then answer the questions.

Survey Notes: Soil and Water in Tamarack Gap

1Tamarack Gap is a town of about 3,000 people in a steep mountain valley in the western United States. Small earthquakes rattle the valley a few times a year, and a fault, a long break in the rock where huge blocks slip past each other, runs along the east side of the valley floor. In 2019, a landslide came down the west side of the valley and broke the pipe that carried the town's water from Spring S1. Now the town council wants a safer water source and land for a community farm. Geologist Mr. Anselm Takeda asked two seventh graders, Odette Kariuki and Bruno Ferraz, to help him survey the valley.

2Soil forms where frost, plant roots and water break bedrock into small grains, and dead plants rot and mix in. On these slopes, bedrock turns into soil at about 0.1 mm a year. Gravity also moves soil downhill, slowly as it creeps a little each year and suddenly in landslides. During floods, the river spreads mud and sand over the valley floor. The team dug five soil pits and measured how thick the soil was (Table 1). Pit C is in the bare scar the 2019 landslide left behind, and Pit D is in the pile of soil and broken rock the landslide dropped at the foot of the slope. The soil in Pit E is made of many thin layers of silt and sand.

3The valley sides are made of two rock layers. The upper layer is sandstone, which has connected spaces between its sand grains, so water moves through it easily. Under it lies shale, made of tightly packed clay, which water can barely move through. The boundary between the two layers is at about 1,450 m above sea level on both sides of the valley. On the west side, the layers tilt gently down toward the valley. On the east side, they tilt gently down away from the valley. Rain and snowmelt soak into the sandstone on the high ridges. Along the fault, earthquakes over many thousands of years have ground the shale into broken, crushed rock. The team measured the flow of every spring in the valley (Table 2). Apart from Spring S4, no water comes out of the shale anywhere in the valley.

Table 1. Soil pits in the valley
PitPlaceSlope (°)Soil thickness (cm)
AFlat ridge top340
BSteep upper slope3510
C2019 landslide scar320
DLandslide pile at foot of slope10180
EValley floor near river1250
1.
Which statement best describes the pattern in Table 1?
Question 1 options
2.
Pits A and E are both on nearly flat ground. Why is the soil in Pit E more than 6 times as thick?
Question 2 options
3.
Circle every pit where most of the soil was carried in from somewhere else.

4.
The 2019 landslide dropped the 180 cm (1,800 mm) of soil in Pit D in a few minutes. Suppose that much soil had to form in place from bedrock at the rate in paragraph 2.

It would take about years to form.

5.
The town wants land for a community farm with soil at least 1 m thick. Where should it look first?
Question 5 options

Where the water comes out

Use paragraph 3 and Table 2 to answer the questions.

Table 2. Springs in the valley
SpringSide of valleyHeight (m)Where it comes outFlow (L/min)
S1West1,450Bottom of sandstone120
S2West1,440Bottom of sandstone96
S3East1,450Bottom of sandstone8
S4East1,250Crushed rock at fault60
6.
Use paragraph 3 and Table 2. Which statement best describes where the springs are?
Question 6 options
7.

Spring S2 gives times as much water per minute as Spring S3.

8.
Why do Springs S1, S2 and S3 come out at about 1,450 m?
Question 8 options
9.
Springs S1 and S3 come out of the same layers at the same height. Why does S1 give 15 times as much water?
Question 9 options
10.
Water can barely move through shale, yet Spring S4 comes out of the shale. Which explanation fits paragraph 3 best?
Question 10 options

Choosing the new water line

Use Table 3, the council's two needs and the survey notes.

The council's needs: 1. The source gives 80 L/min or more. 2. The pipe does not cross the 2019 landslide scar or the fault, where landslides and earthquakes can break it.
Table 3. Water line options
OptionSourceFlow (L/min)Pipe route
ARebuild line from S1120Crosses the landslide scar
BNew line from S296Along a gentle ridge
CNew line from S38Along a gentle ridge
DNew line from S460Crosses the fault
ES3 and S4 together68Crosses the fault
11.
Which option meets both of the council's needs?
Question 11 options
12.
In the next valley to the north, the same sandstone sits on the same shale at about 1,450 m. There, the layers tilt down toward the valley on its east side and away from it on its west side. Where should the team expect the strongest springs?
Question 12 options
13.
Write a note to the town council explaining why the farm and the new water source must go in particular places, not just where land is cheapest. Make a claim, use evidence from at least two tables, and explain your reasoning with the geologic processes that put the soil and water where they are.